What scholars have said

Can I ask an AI about Islam?

Fatwa bodies have answered this, some of them strictly. Here is what three of them said, in our own words and with links to their own pages, and what it means for how Hilm is built.

What they said

  1. Uzbekistan

    13 June 2025

    The Fatwa Center of the Muslim Board of Uzbekistan

    A question and answer on the Board’s website

    Asked whether a person may get answers to religious questions from ChatGPT and act on them, it answered: “No, this is not permissible.”

    • ChatGPT helps in some fields, but it can’t be relied on to answer questions of religion correctly.
    • It sometimes guesses, and has even quoted Arabic lines as coming from a named book when they appear neither there nor in other books of fiqh.
    • Questions of the Shariah should be taken to people of knowledge. It pointed to the Qur’an’s instruction to ask those who know (21:7).

    Read it on muslim.uz (in Uzbek; the quote is our translation)

  2. Egypt

    2 December 2025

    Egypt’s Dar al-Ifta

    A fatwa: “Using AI applications to obtain fatwas”

    It ruled that relying on AI applications to obtain a fatwa is impermissible.

    • Giving a fatwa is a weighty task that needs a qualified, accountable person.
    • AI answers fall short of the precision that takes: sometimes right, sometimes wrong or at odds with settled rulings.
    • They follow no sound method for deriving rulings, and can’t tell which texts carry authority.
    • Many rulings turn on custom, time and place, which no app weighs the way a qualified mufti does.
    • Using AI is permissible in itself, it added: what it is used for decides the ruling.

    Read it on dar-alifta.org

  3. Jordan

    26 April 2026

    An article published by Jordan’s General Iftaa’ Department

    By AbdulRahman al-Sharif, a researcher. An article, not one of the department’s fatwas.

    No machine can issue a fatwa or be counted as a mufti. AI can help scholars gather and compare texts, under their oversight and on their responsibility.

    It warns people who ask questions against:

    • Trusting answers that no scholar has checked.
    • Reading a short answer, or a text, out of its context.
    • Forgetting that their own situation matters to the answer.

    Read it on aliftaa.jo

We read each of these pages again on 18 November 2026. If one of these bodies changes its view, we’ll change this page and say when.

For Hilm

What that means for how Hilm is built

  • Hilm doesn’t issue fatwas. It tells you what the books of the four Sunni schools say, and shows you where, so you can check.
  • Every point needs a source, and quotes are matched word for word against the original before you see them.
  • For a ruling on your own situation, it points you to a scholar who knows it.
  • It can be wrong, so every answer shows its sources.

If you follow the stricter view

Some scholars hold that you shouldn’t take religious answers from an AI at all. If that is the view you follow, you can still use Hilm’s prayer times, qibla and Qur’an, and take your questions to a scholar you trust.

Calm, honest, and on your side.

Coming soon

For iPhone and Android